Pediatric Cardiology
Worcester - Fitchburg - Framingham - Yarmouthport

 

Home
Locations
Hospitals
Patient information
Research
Contact us

Appointments

Kid Stuff

Hit Counter

 

GO Network
GO Kids | GO Family | GO Money | GO Sports | GO Home
Infoseek Search
  
ABCNEWS
   WEB
  
  
GO Network ABOUT GO NETWORK | SIGN IN | FREE E-MAIL
Register Now!
HOME

NEWS SUMMARY

U.S.

POLITICS

WORLD

BUSINESS

TECHNOLOGY

SCIENCE

HEALTH&LIVING

TRAVEL

ESPN SPORTS

ENTERTAINMENT

WEATHER.com

REFERENCE

LOCAL

ABCNEWS ON TV


LIVING HEADLINES

New Heart Devices Could Help Thousands

Studies: Colon Cancer Diet Doubtful

Study: Counseling Cuts Down on Kids

What's Wrong With U.S. Playgrounds?

Is Managed Care Hurting Heart Patients?


ABCNEWS.com

Special Offers



SEARCH

FAMILY.COM

ABC.com

EMAIL
    ABCNEWS.com


SEND PAGE TO
    A FRIEND


TOOLS AND
    HELPERS






EKG
Managed Care Fails Hearts
Managed care insurance leaves patients with no
choice and a higher chance of death


Researchers say that heart bypass patients covered by managed care insurance plans were less likely to be sent to better quality hospitals, where fewer people died after such procedures. (PhotoDisc)
 
By Michael Colon
Reuters
C H I C A G O, April 18 —A study of heart bypass patients has found that those covered by managed care insurance plans were less likely to be sent to better quality hospitals, where fewer people died after such procedures, researchers reported today.
    
“An excellent take-home message (from this study) is that patients and doctors need to take control back,” said Lars Erickson of Children’s Hospital in Boston, chief author of the report.
     “They need to use information that has been painstakingly collected by the state (on hospital quality). The problem with managed care is that you have to make that decision when you sign up. You can’t wait until you’re sick,” he said in an interview.
     The study looked at 58,902 patients hospitalized for coronary artery bypass surgery in New York state from 1993 to 1996. It did not track what happened to those patients but it did show which hospitals they were sent to, hospitals which Erickson said had specifically been ranked as high- or low-mortality institutions based on bypass surgery outcomes.
     Compared with patients with private fee-for-service insurance, patients with private managed care insurance, which usually specifies which hospital and doctor can be used, were 23 percent less likely to receive the surgery at a lower-mortality hospital, the study found. Medicare managed care insurance patients undergoing the same procedure were 39 percent less likely to have it at a lower mortality hospital.
     The report was published in this week’s Journal of the American Medical Association.

Patients Need More Control
“By limiting patient choices, managed care organizations may prevent patients and their advocates from taking full advantage of available information about hospital quality,” said the report.
     “This could inadvertently stifle incentives for hospitals to compete on the quality of care,” it added. “Additional studies on the impact of quality information on health plans’ contracting decisions will be important as price competition among health plans becomes more intense…
     “Financial risk provides a strong incentive for health plans to select low-priced hospitals. However, health plans should also consider quality of care when contracting with hospitals, especially if explicit data on quality are available,” the study said.
     Conditions vary from state to state, and non-insurance factors also influence where patients seek care; but Erickson told Reuters: “One thing that is very clear is that if people don’t start taking an active role in figuring out which hospital is best for them, those choices are being taken away from them.”
     In an editorial in the same issue commenting on the study, Stephen Jencks of the federal government’s Health Care Financing Administration said a number of studies have found that patients “rank quality information far behind convenience, coverage, access, and cost in choosing health plans … consumers make clear that they value information on health choices from friends, family, and personal physicians much more than information from government sources.”
     But he said information on quality must be made available even though it probably will not “reshape the marketplace in the short run.”

Copyright 2000 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

 SEARCH ABCNEWS.com FOR MORE ON …

Related Stories
Subconscious Bias in Heart Care?

Heart Attacks More Fatal in Women

HMO Horror Stories

Trust Goes Only So Far





Copyright ©2000 ABC News Internet Ventures. Click here for Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Internet Safety Information applicable to this site.

 

Webmaster - Copyright © 1999-2013

Please Note: The contents of these web pages are provided for general information purposes and do not constitute medical advice for specific individuals, which should only be obtained from a physician. Any information offered by Dr. Erickson via this web site or by email is solely out of courtesy and does not constitute a doctor-patient relationship between you and Dr. Erickson.  Dr. Erickson is not responsible for the content provided at any external link sites.